its so cuteAll Manga, Character Designs and Logos are © to their respective copyright holders.
REVIEWS
WikatoriaPretty good on Akai Ito no Shikkou Yuuyo
Pretty good
Reply
Meh on The Lazy Swordmaster
Nuh uh. Nope. This isn't it. Gotta try again. I don't usually like to trash stuff. Well, I like to trash-talk you people, but not really mangas. There are two reasons for that: the general rating standards for this site are rather generous, so I adapted to that, helping myself with the Ivern Scale™️... and it's not great to demean people's efforts gratuitously.
But I gotta draw a line sometimes. So this is a 3 stars, but on a low end of them. It's a 6+ on the Ivern Scale. Why? Ooooooh boy. Here we go.
Art? No. Style is too cartoony, to begin with, but the quality itself is also low.
Writing? Dear g** help us withstanding it. The translation adds insult to injury. In a word, worthless.
The action? It commits the worst sin a shonen can commit: being mediocre and boring, but inoffensive. Worse than luckwarm, actively sleep inducing. MC is very powerful. He swings sword very very hard yo. People die when he flails the thing, y'know. That's it.
Characterization? See, that's where I get disappointed. A lazy (read: PTSD-ridden) ex savior who tries to escape another god**** hero journey? Yes please! But the fuc**** execution is so fuc**** plain I can't even consider it an attempt. Again, with the "victim girl learns to live for herself" trope too: it could be mad interesting, and it is wasted. I genuinely like Riley's relationship with his mother, but once again it's more like the idea of it. Not what I actually got.
It's all very clumsy. It's a mixed reccomendation from yours truly. Passable, I'd guess, but only as a last resort if you have read literally everything else in the genre. Even then, good luck.
But I gotta draw a line sometimes. So this is a 3 stars, but on a low end of them. It's a 6+ on the Ivern Scale. Why? Ooooooh boy. Here we go.
Art? No. Style is too cartoony, to begin with, but the quality itself is also low.
Writing? Dear g** help us withstanding it. The translation adds insult to injury. In a word, worthless.
The action? It commits the worst sin a shonen can commit: being mediocre and boring, but inoffensive. Worse than luckwarm, actively sleep inducing. MC is very powerful. He swings sword very very hard yo. People die when he flails the thing, y'know. That's it.
Characterization? See, that's where I get disappointed. A lazy (read: PTSD-ridden) ex savior who tries to escape another god**** hero journey? Yes please! But the fuc**** execution is so fuc**** plain I can't even consider it an attempt. Again, with the "victim girl learns to live for herself" trope too: it could be mad interesting, and it is wasted. I genuinely like Riley's relationship with his mother, but once again it's more like the idea of it. Not what I actually got.
It's all very clumsy. It's a mixed reccomendation from yours truly. Passable, I'd guess, but only as a last resort if you have read literally everything else in the genre. Even then, good luck.
Reply
(9)
Meh on My Daughter is a Dragon!
great story, i swear i love it, but the problem is that the daugher just gives everything to the father like a drug. seen pepole talk about both of them managing to overcome obstacles, but its more like "is your father weak, then ill just give him strenght. but it has to be renewed every night and if he doesnt get it renewed he gets back to square 1", i think the plot should've something like "is your father weak, then ill give him the power to be strong, so even if the power runs out, he's still strong"
same with the newest chapter (47), instead of allowing him to become a good soldier, she just cheats and gives him the power to shoot every target, but thats only if he uses the gun that the girl modified.
the sad part is that since the father doesnt know what his daughter is doing, he actually thinks that he's improving, wich is sad beacuse it means that he's not learning anything and if his daughter where to leave (unlikely but so) he would be back to square 1, and could actually lose more than square 1 since everyone now has expectations on him
same with the newest chapter (47), instead of allowing him to become a good soldier, she just cheats and gives him the power to shoot every target, but thats only if he uses the gun that the girl modified.
the sad part is that since the father doesnt know what his daughter is doing, he actually thinks that he's improving, wich is sad beacuse it means that he's not learning anything and if his daughter where to leave (unlikely but so) he would be back to square 1, and could actually lose more than square 1 since everyone now has expectations on him
Reply
(4)
Rocks on Lady Crystal is a Man
such a lovley manhwa!! beautiful art, cute trope and such a unique story line!! i love it so much - plz give it a read!!
such a lovley manhwa!! beautiful art, cute trope and such a unique story line!! i love it so much - plz give it a read!!Reply
(3)
Pretty good on Company and Private Life
So far it's a pretty decent Gender Bender, the characters are super cute in their alt personas but the story hasn't progressed enough to get a read on their personalities.
Might be a tad harsh, but knocking a star off because of the two panel chapter upload. Not sure if it's exactly how they're translated or if the uploader is only doing two panels at a time, but it kinda leaves you hanging especially when a scene goes across several chapters.
Might be a tad harsh, but knocking a star off because of the two panel chapter upload. Not sure if it's exactly how they're translated or if the uploader is only doing two panels at a time, but it kinda leaves you hanging especially when a scene goes across several chapters.
Reply
(2)
